Three-modality exogenous evoked
potentials (TMEPs) have been used since several years as a prognostic
tool in acute anoxic or traumatic coma. The whole information
provided by TMEPs can be summarized by means of two indices :
the index of global cortical function (IGCF), derived from flash
visual and cortical somatosensory EPs, and the index of brain-stem
conduction (IBSC), derived from subcortical somatosensory and
brainstem auditory EPs. The IGCF is expressed by grades : Grade
0 corresponds to normal (never encountered in comatose patients),
Grade 1 and 2 to the variable preservation of associative cortical
activities, Grade 3 to the sole preservation of primary cortical
activities, and Grade 4 to the loss of all cortical EPs with preservation
of brain-stem components. The IBSC is firstly quantitatively determined,
and, if abnormal, qualitatively rated in terms of midbrain, pontine
or medullar involvement.
Anoxic comas are associated with prognostically relevant IGCF
abnormalities while the IBSC remains intact (Pattern 1). For examinations
performed between the 1st and the 3d day after the acute episode,
Grade 1 and Grade 2 were associated in our series with a 64% and
38% rate of good outcome, respectively, while we never observed
any recovery in patients with Grade 4 more than 24 hours after
the acute episode.
Head trauma is associated with both IGCF and IBSC alterations
and the abnormalities can be clustered into 4 patterns : hemispheric
damage without brain-stem involvement (Pattern 1), midbrain dysfunction
(Pattern 2), transtentorial herniation (Pattern 3), brain death
(Pattern 4). In our series of traumatic patients with Pattern
1, IGCF Grade 1 and Grade 2 observed within the first 3 days were
associated with 89% and 78% rates of good outcome, respectively.
The outcome of patients with Pattern 2 depended on the extent
of hemispheric diffuse axonal lesions (HDAL) associated with the
midbrain lesion (67% of good outcome in the absence of HDAL, 20%
of good outcome in the presence of HDAL). Therefore, we suggest
performing MRI in patients with Pattern 2. Patterns 3 and 4 were
always associated with death.
Thus, it appears that strongly altered exogenous EPs are always
associated with an ominous prognosis. Mildly altered exogenous
EPs were associated with a better prognosis in our series, although
36% of anoxic and 13% of traumatic patients with mildly altered
EPs presented a poor evolution. We examined whether the presence
of cognitive EPs (oddball paradigm) recorded in passive conditions
could be associated with a better prognosis. These were recorded
in more than 150 anoxic and traumatic comatose patients (GCS £
8). Although the P3b component was almost never obtainable, the
mismatch negativity (MMN) and the P3a component were recordable
in more than 20% of patients, and their persistence was associated
in more than 90% of cases with some consciousness recovery. Moreover,
the latencies of both the MMN and the P3a were significantly correlated
with the GCS (p < 0.006). Thus, while the absence of cognitive
EPs in comatose patients doesn't have any prognostic value, their
presence implies a very high probability of consciousness recovery.
As such, cognitive EPs may very usefully complement exogenous
EPs as a prognostic tool in coma.
Selected references:
Guerit JM, Fischer C, Facco E, Tinuper P, Murri L, Ronne-Engstrom
E, Nuwer M. Standards of clinical practice of EEG and EPs in comatose
and other unresponsive states. The International Federation of
Clinical Neurophysiology. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol
Suppl. 1999;52:117-31
Guerit JM. Medical technology assessment EEG and evoked potentials
in the intensive care
unit. Neurophysiol Clin. 1999 Sep;29(4):301-17
Guerit JM, Verougstraete D, de Tourtchaninoff M, Debatisse D,
Witdoeckt C. ERPs obtained with the auditory oddball paradigm
in coma and altered states of consciousness: clinical relationships,
prognostic value, and origin of components. Clin Neurophysiol.
1999 Jul;110(7):1260-9